Agency,identity and learning at turning points in women's lives: towards a comparative UK-Italian analysis
Author(s):
Karen Evans (presenting / submitting) Chiara Biasin (presenting)
Conference:
ECER 2014
Format:
Paper

Session Information

02 SES 02 A, VET and Learning: Changing Lives

Paper Session

Time:
2014-09-02
15:15-16:45
Room:
B023 Anfiteatro
Chair:
Trine Deichman-Sørensen
Discussant:
Geoff Hayward

Contribution

The concept of trajectories is typically used in work on transitions of young adults into the labour market, providing ideal type, segmented routes that can be used to understand a variety of personal histories (Evans and Heinz 1994). In adult life, routes diverge, experiences diversify still further and  multiplicities of new contingencies come into play (Ecclestone et al 2009; Alheit and Dausien 2002; Biesta, 2007; Biasin 2012). In researching adults’ life and work experiences, initial career  trajectories take on historical significance. Trajectories start, in early life, with family relationships, with educational achievement, moving onto occupational choices, applying for and taking up jobs and the processes of establishing independent personal and family lives. These processes continue in adult life with activities undertaken with the aims of maintaining employment, changing employment, balancing work and family life, taking risks, seeking stability, finding personal fulfilment. They often involve changes in the adult’s orientations to learning, work and family. This paper discusses the ways in which women aged 50, in contrasting cultural contexts, narrate and portray turning points in their life course, with particular reference to the relationships between identity, agency and learning, including  opportunities to  learn through work and life experiences . These accounts reflect identity and the complex sets of adults’ motivations, beliefs and attitudes towards learning and their own capabilities to achieve in and through learning (Kirpal, 2011). Their orientations can also change according to specific experiences of success or failure, opportunities or setbacks at any stage. Orientations towards work and career, similarly, comprise complex sets of motivations, beliefs and attitudes rooted in actual life experiences and social structuring of the lifecourse. 

In the conceptual framework for exploration of women’s representations of turning points in their lives, we draw on theories of life course (Heinz 2001) and, in particular,  approaches with particular relevance to the study of women at the age of fifty, assumed as an age of specific transitions in the  life course (Sugarman 1986).  The gender perspective in this field will be examined. The exercise of agency is understood as a bounded process that is exercised through environments, drawing on Evans ( 2002; 2007; 2009)  and Biesta et al (2011).Furthermore, the biographical learning perspectives of Alheit, Tedder and Biesta, and Goodson reveal aspects of the narrative-in-action which permits the research participants to negotiate and to make claims about different life events and about life course. These are dominant perspectives in European scholarship and research  in adult learning.

The life experiences and women’s representations of them also reflect cultural norms and expectations about the adult life course, particularly with respect to gender roles and relationships. Initial analysis of narratives and drawings (sketches) of 17 women born in 1958, selected from the 220 in-depth qualitative interviews conducted as a sub-study of the UK National Cohort Studies (NCDS), has been completed and is now being extended, as a second stage, to the analysis of comparable transcripts and drawings provided by a sample of  women of the same age in Italy. This is part of a UK-Italian collaboration hosted by the ESRC Learning and Life Chances in Knowledge Economies and Societies (LLAKES Centre)

Research questions: How do women’s representations of the life course reflect the relationship between agency, identity and learning? To what extent do representations of the life course of women who have grown up and lived their lives in Italy suggest shared features or differences from those of the women in the UK NCDS sample? How might these shared and contrasting features be explored further to elucidate the intertwining of identity, agency and learning with cultural norms and expectations?

 

 .

Method

The methodology is designed to expore the narrative and symbolic representations of turning points in the narratives of the research participants. This approach is informed by Mattingly (2007), with the aim of (a) understanding the implicit meaning (tacit and naive theory-in-use) of the ideas of turning points and movements 'up and down' as expressed in the narratives and sketches (b) showing the relationship between agency, learning and identity embedded in these narratives (c) elucidating how different cultural roles and expectations are reflected in women's representations, to lay the foundations for a longer term comparative study of interviews and drawings from women in UK and Italy. The first data source is the set of 220 interviews conducted with respondents in England, Scotland and Wales in the study deposited in the UK Archives Data under the "Social participation and Identity" project. From this study, a sub-sample of the 1958 National Child Development Study cohort, we chose the female sub-sample of 110 interviews. From these 110 interviews, we have analysed four sections related to life history and to identity. Furthermore we selected the thirty-one interviews in which women have drawn a diagram representing their life course and, from these, we further selected seventeen interviews in which the turning points in the life course were represented as up and down lines. According to a comparative approach, the second data source will be a set of interviews and life course drawings/diagrams provided by Italian women of fifty years old. As a first step, this approach is being tested with 5 Italian women, with a view to obtaining a full sample matched to the UK sample as second stage. The methodological approach is qualitative: ● The content analysis is made on the transcriptions with Nvivo, including the thematic, the linguistic and the narrative analysis. ● The validity of the results is constantly verified by a continuous process of discussion and by a compared analysis conducted by the two authors (UK and Italian) both separately and together.

Expected Outcomes

● We expect to improve understanding of the factors which are represented as important in the life history narratives of the women. ● Examining women's interviews we expect to recognize different patterns of the relationship between agency, identity and learning, tracing a variety of recurrent models ● Similarities and differences in the life histories will be shown and compared regarding the different modes used by women to draw and to narrate their life history. Particular attention will be given to the cultural expectations and gendered dimensions of roles and relationships in comparing the women's histories and diagrams from the two countries. The findings and lessons learned from the exploratory comparative analysis are enabling us to design a more extensive comparative study between matched samples in UK and Italy, building on Biasin's 2012 previous research, as a second stage. Initial exploration of personal accounts of adult learning show how specific relationships and workplace experiences can act as ‘activating events’ that have the potential to not only trigger new ‘learning orientations’ (values, attitudes towards learning) but may also forge new ‘career orientations’. These can entail greater confidence and willingness on the part of women to develop themsleves in new ways. However, the impact of these shifting orientations on life trajectories, and the degree to which such changes can be sustained over time, depend on personal, cultural and institutional factors. In some cases, ‘activating events’ that have triggered new work attitudes and motivations to learn, sometimes with ‘tipping points’ being reached in and through significant relationships that have nudged some women towards broadening of their horizons and galvanising of their willingness to take on more challenging roles. In others, recurrent patterns of crisis and the search for stability characterise the ups and downs and turning points of the life course, in culturally-specific ways.

References

Alheit, P., Dausien, B. (2002). The double face of lifelong learning. Two analytical perspective on a silent revolution. "Studies in Education of Adults", 34, 1, 3-22. Andrews, M., Squire, C., Tamboukou, M. (2008). Doing Narrarive Research. London: Sage. Biasin, C., (2012). Le transizioni. Modelli e approcci per l'educazione degli adulti. Lecce: Pensa Multimedia Biesta, G., Field, J., Hodkinson, P., Macleod, F., Goodson, I. (2011). Improving Learning through the Lifecourse. London: Routledge. Ecclestone, K., Biesta, G. and Hughes, M. (eds) (2009) Lost in Transition?: Change and Becoming through the Lifecourse, London: Routledge Falmer Evans, K., Behrens, M and Kaluza, J. (2000) Learning and Work in the Risk Society: Lessons for the labour markets of Europe from Eastern Germany, Basingstoke: Palgrave. Evans, K. (2009) Learning Work and Social Responsibility: challenges for lifelong learning in a global age. Dordrecht: Springer. Evans, K. and Heinz, W.R. Heinz (1994) Becoming Adults in England and Germany, Anglo-German Foundation, London and Bonn Evans, K. (2007). Concepts of bounded agency in education, work, and the personal lives of young adults. "International Journal of Psychology", 42, 2, 85-93. Evans, K., Waite, E. (2013). 'Activating events' in adult learners'lives. Understanding learning and life change through a retrospective lens. In H.Helve, K.Evans, Youth and work transitions in changing social landscapes. London: Tuffnell, 195-217. Goodson I. (2013). Developing Narrative Theory. London: Routledge. Heinz, W.R. and Krüger, H.(2001) Life Course: Innovations and Challenges for Social Research Current Sociology March 2001 vol. 49 no. 2 29-45 Mattingly, C.F. (2007). Acted Narratives. From storytelling to emergent dramas. In D.J.Clandinin (Ed.). Handbook of Narrative Inquiry. London: Sage, 405-425 Kirpal, S. (2011) Labour-Market Flexibility and Individual Careers: A Comparative Study, Dordrecht: Springer. Sugarman, S. (1986) Life-span Development: Theories, Concepts and Interventions, Routledge. Tedder, M., Biesta, G. (2007). Agency and learning in the lifecourse. Towards an ecological perspective. " Studies on Education of Adults", 39, 2, 139-149. Tedder, M., Biesta, G. (2009). Biography, transitions and learning in the life course. In J.Field, J.Gallacher, R.Ingram (eds.). Researching transitions in lifelong learning (pp.76-90). London: Routledge. Webster, L, Mertova, P. (2007). Using Narrative Inquiry as a Research Methods. London: Routledge.

Author Information

Karen Evans (presenting / submitting)
Institute of Education, University of London
Lifelong and Comparative Education
Pulborough
Chiara Biasin (presenting)
University of Padua, Italy

Update Modus of this Database

The current conference programme can be browsed in the conference management system (conftool) and, closer to the conference, in the conference app.
This database will be updated with the conference data after ECER. 

Search the ECER Programme

  • Search for keywords and phrases in "Text Search"
  • Restrict in which part of the abstracts to search in "Where to search"
  • Search for authors and in the respective field.
  • For planning your conference attendance, please use the conference app, which will be issued some weeks before the conference and the conference agenda provided in conftool.
  • If you are a session chair, best look up your chairing duties in the conference system (Conftool) or the app.